Loud enough for us to hear :( Food was good unfortunately they have a very limited menu and they dont state that on the website. The menu is small but the food is amazing the waffel and chicken is great !!! We also were feted to a dessert that wasn't on the menu which was a mixture of devils food cake, mousse, and other goodies.hope it gets on the menu. During this Covid-19 transition especially with the lack of staffing, we strive to accommodate all of our guests needs. Good was great! All too often, these eateries either miss out on what we have in our own backyard or mask the vibrant produce with heavy sauces or overwrought preparations. The bar tender was also doing everything else that night ,taking orders and serving the food ! When I shop, I always shop daily. Third time we packed it to go since everyone else had finished their meals. The dinners were exceptional and so was the service. OpenTable is part of Booking Holdings, the world leader in online travel and related services. the kitchen with water and to take our drink orders. We will most certainly do our best to create a space welcoming to both former guests and newcomers. - Maidstone Management. Then I cut into the duck which I had to "saw" it with my knife because it was overcooked. The Maidstone is rated 4 stars by 889 OpenTable diners. Recently I went to California and I was looking at healthy restaurants. They were a little short staffed, but so is everyone now, so we all need to show a bit more patience. company and keep drinking. I've NEVER had a problem with myfood here, and again, we live close and have been coming here for years.More, The ricotta gnudi pasta was an absolute explosion of flavor. Service at the INN has gone down hillllllll. at the computer on the left wanted nothing to do with dealing with anyone for the restaurant, felt like there was some kind of rivalry happening. I think you need acid, so definitely some brightness, and then just the freshest vegetables you can find is what you should serve with good seafood. Unfortunate you did not have an enjoyable experience with us at such a magical corner here in East Hampton. Great service from a restaurant that had been inconsistent in the past. Very creative interpretation of duck lorange. So its kind of vacation food, but healthy-ish. I think the kind of food we do at Cloverhealth focus and a little lighterlends itself well here. If you have eaten at Living Room in last years be aware (as I was not) that restaurant is under new manager with a very limited menu. Staff seems very disinterested in providing good service and food was just awful. Cool, scrub, clean, wash, and sanitize. Great bartender and good drinks at the bar. I waited patiently for my duck. We have to ask staff to remove the charge for what we received. What a disappointment!More, I was a bit nervous about coming g here given the mixed reviews but we had a great team and a very good meal. The waitstaff could not be more polite or attentive. Youre only out here during the summer, which is why we wanted to go light anyway, so it was just a great perfect mix of concepts. - Maidstone Management. Part of the meal that was ordered never arrived and we were charged. I will be back. I mean, I am not really sure how often I will get to do this in life, but I am excited to have gained the knowledge and experience! The bar tender then was sharing true stories about women with a friend at the bar ! The outdoor garden was delightful and pet-friendly. Save your money and skip this place! Swedish meatballs were pasty and tasted like something canned for pets. Can't imagine that there was a manager on the floor and certainly didn't see anyone that might be one. Creepy. Order Online I finally was able to check in with our reservation upon which he told us to wait in the bar area20 minutes later one of our friends walks past to go to the ladies room and asked us why we were so late!!!! Beautiful spot in East Hamptons historic district which is convenient for several area sites. The atmosphere in the Hamptons is very old school and rustic and I just want pie. Then I took the two hour drive home. Wish there were more selections on the Wine list but it was good wine at a fair price. Spoon the foaming butter over the uncooked side of the scallops until cooked to medium rare. The Maidstone has so much potential but it was empty and the food was just ok. Its the first thing I decided to put on the dessert menu. It has been difficult staffing and filling all the normal roles due to covid-19 and the lack there of staffing. What inspired the expansion to the Hamptons this summer? The room also has nothing to absorb noise so it gets very loud. We sat at a low table with a love seat and chairs, tucked in by the fireplace. The MaidstoneResponded on August 28, 2021Unfortunate you did not have an enjoyable experience with us at such a magical corner here in East Hampton. Wont last in Hamptons. The Maidstone Restaurant is rated accordingly in the following categories by Tripadvisor travelers: Can a vegetarian person get a good meal at this restaurant? Photography by Winnie Au. WedSun 5:00 pm9:00 pm Thank you for your honest feedback, for that's the best way to improve. What are the essentials that everyone should have in their pantry? I think the mistake that people make is do too much. When well colored on one side, reduce heat to medium and add 2 tablespoons of the turmeric lime butter. Tripadvisor performs checks on reviews. Mix well and then chill overnight. The kitchen ran out of fish, by 7:00, the drinks took over 20 min to arrive at our table- then when we finished by 9:30 we were told the kitchen had closed, dessert wasnt available and that the espresso machine was broken. - F&B Management. Upon arriving at the restaurant and looking at the menu I didn't see the Seafood Bowl and when I asked the waited I was told it was no longer available and they had to update the website. We left a little over an hour after we were seated - which was the pace we wanted. They were so salted, they were barely edible. Nicely decorated but space has lost some of its ethos since its heyday years ago. Fun fun fun. Service with an attitude! Shared on MyDomaine We had a nice (Apple/citrus finish) Sauvignon Blanc by the glass - the restaurant has a wonderful variety of by-the-glass wines for every palate. Great place for lunch and wine in a beautiful setting. Egg in a hole with parsley butter. There is so much to savor in our immediate surroundings, from day boat scallops locally caught off our shores to vegetables that have just been plucked from the earth less than a mile away. We will hope for a comeback! Lobster roll the best we ever had. Food was terrific. The food was ok- the service was very slow, we were one of four groups of 2-4 at the entire restaurant. MonThu, Sun 5:00 pm9:00 pm Our server Greg was fantastic!More, Food was mediocre. Its been a summer of great food in the hamptons. I will definitely be back! I asked the front desk man if we could order some food , he was very friendly and embarrassed that we had not ordered yet . Shuck the scallops by running a knife along the inside of the flat part of the shell, opening the scallop and pulling the gills and liver off of the scallop. Sushi was not memorable. The Maidstone is a mainstay in East Hampton. Originally I was thinking about what our clientele at Caf Clover would want to eat while on vacation. It has been difficult staffing and filling all the normal roles due to covid-19 and the lack there of staffing. Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. We made seared diver scallops with turmeric, lime butter, black lentils and ginger chive. Look around and you will find a better place for less We are very happy to have returned for a delightful Sunday brunch in a very pleasant and relaxed setting. Now here we were again, only a short while after his taking the helm of the kitchen at The Maidstone, making another superb lentil dish together scallops with turmeric lime butter, black lentils and ginger chives. Its all about aesthetics and a controlled color palette, people!) However, the AC blows very cold air in from one side of the room. We had a table in the interior dining room. This place used to be great until they changed chefs. The front desk man was really nice and tried as hard as he could to do his best . It has been around for ages built in 1740 and was previously a bed & breakfast before being purchased and reimagined by Swedish hotelier Jenny Ljungberg in 2008. Dinners came 10 min apart. Designed By Amy Risley | Developed By maude_rewrite, Caf Altro Paradiso Bake Sale Planned Parenthood, The Perfect Weeknight Family Meal with Daphne Oz + Eden Grinshpan, In My Kitchen with Daphne Oz + Eden Grinshpan, 6 scallops, preferably live and in the shell, 1 cup dried black lentils cooked in salted water, 2 teaspoons chopped herbs (tarragon, chives, dill, parsley). Its unfortunate as we were really looking forward to a special meal. Well I received the sweet potato puree along with the snap peas and carrots which were cooked perfectly. Thank you for dining with us and we are striving daily to improve our service and the quality of our food. Within minutes, Sara, our cheerful server, came out fromthe kitchen with water and to take our drink orders. Warm, delicious French bread and drinks came out within 10 minutes of our sitting down. (Ill be honest the mimosa was too orange for the photo, hence the switch to the pink-hued drink. This is the silver lining. Come on in and take a look! Extremely clean and the staff is amazing and very accomodating. Love the atmosphere. In a past visit we had seared scallops which were expertly prepared. Mediocre, at best, service. Everything was on the fly, taking our order, delivering our orders and drinks. The hostess and waitress were charming and welcoming. Restaurant is under new management so it is now a bar menu. What is your ideal summer dessert? All it takes are simple ideas and thoughtful execution to turn our surroundings into a place that makes the eye swoon. Oh, and dog friendly! So was the chicken Milanese. What a disappointment! Ghost service but the rest was outstanding and the food very very light like we like it. New menu is excellent. Wouldnt give it a second to around based on that experience. Can you tell me about the dish we made together? Chef Ian Lowell apparently is imaginative andsuccessful. Our food is only getting better, Thank you. Get quick answers from The Maidstone Restaurant staff and past visitors. As a duck breast aficionado, I know that duck breast, cooked correctly, should be able to slice with one pass of the knife. Between the fresh, clean food and fresh, clean digs, youll want to check out The Maidstone. Detailed Reviews: Reviews order informed by descriptiveness of user-identified themes such as cleanliness, atmosphere, general tips and location information. The food is ALWAYS good. As a hotel it is incredibly expensive ! Great service and simple, but delicious menu. We will certainly miss the former Living Room at Maidstone. This review is the subjective opinion of a Tripadvisor member and not of Tripadvisor LLC. Nothing to right home about. Chef David and I have known one another for about two years. Look around and you will find a better place for less We loved the ambiance and the fireplace the most. In the meantime, read on for a little Q + A with Chef David and I as we talked favorite ingredients and cooking styles while eating scallops for breakfast at 10 a.m., sipping on both mimosas and ros. Boil the curved sides of the shells in water with a lot of vinegar and salt. Its a lovely setting - a refined, yet eclectic mix of old and new with a gas fireplace to provide ambience. Definitely kosher salt. Another year, another theme at The Maidstone! The food was good but not the breadth or quality of Living Room, more bar type food. - no mention was made of it again. I'm a regular and live down the street, so thus double embarrassedThere was no one to greet us and the gentlemanat the computer on the left wanted nothing to do with dealing with anyone for the restaurant, felt like there was some kind of rivalry happening. Interior renovation is just lovely! The staff were pretty rude about it. We needed a quick getaway and this restaurant was the perfect distraction. -Maidstone Management. The new more casual format is very nice and relaxing. Would love to know what you ordered so we can make adjustments in the future. The service was awkward .maybe because they just reopened .the bar was very slow. Dinner was a hot mess. As a hotel it is incredibly expensive ! Does this restaurant offer table service? The waitstaff could not have been more attentive! Very excited for this restaurant this year. minutes later we got a menu and ordered some wine then nothing happened for 40 minutes !! more. Horrific. Well be back! I couldnt really find anyeverything was kind of healthy, but no one was wearing it on their sleeves like, Im cooking healthy. It was just healthy, from the garden, and very fresh. When I asked the waited what was taking so long, I told him I hoped they weren't overcooking it. Not a good start . 207 Main St, East Hampton, NY 11937 Even the coffee was good. Menu needs a clearer POV. They were inventive and delicious. Skip this place, the food is a waste of money. Menu choices were limited but good tasting,especially the spaghetti with clam saucethe best ! Could use more choices. We will most certainly do our best to create a space welcoming to both former guests and newcomers. The inside outside dinning experince has swing that lights up , pingpong and a trampoline. Food menu was limited this year due to covid 19 but food they had coming out was fantastic. I always thought it would be a good fit and then we just got the opportunity. And absolutely not worth the money ! Nicely decorated but space has lost some of its ethos since its heyday years ago. They were just worried about getting us out as fast as possible. Apparently, the venue changed ownership/management and with that, so much has changed at the restaurant. The food found nearby doesnt need much to shine. As someone with a love for fresh, local, seasonal ingredients, it baffles me that more restaurants in the Hamptons do not capitalize on the many farms that congregate on the East End of Long Island. I wanted to cut my losses. Not cheap, but worth it.More, My friend had wanted to visit this restaurant for a long time . The dish is super flavorful yet simple enough to let the beauty of each ingredient shine. The Maitre D was running around like he had lost his wallet. Ambience, service all great. The guy never apologized or even owned up to the mess up! The Inn ambiance is charming,and the prices are no higher than most Hamptons restaurants now. They both worked very hard Nothing like Hampton summer nights. was very disappointing. To make matters worse, a couple who had a large chocolate lab seating in the path way to the back room, (no one ever asked the couple to tuck the dog near the table, before getting stepped on or tripping a waiter) We had a running bet on the accident waiting to happen. Great service from a restaurant that had been inconsistent in the past. The two gentleman, one was the bar tender, were able to handle everything, just took a little longer than usual. Staff are abundantly friendly and helpful, especially bar staff where we drank and ate. Not really. Thats really the key. and the food was really good. I always have cooking oil and olive oil. I always ask myself, what can I take away from that complicated composition and still have something great? Go sample Chef Davids dishes and experience the beautiful, renovated lobby, complete with one room clad in soft pink and the other in a deep, rich turquoise. Swedish meatballs were pasty and tasted like something canned for pets. Young and fun !!!!!! It was a nice evening at The Maidstone. To top things off our waiter took everyone else order around us and then took ours last..There is no reason for such an established restaurant to treat customers so poorly and not be able to handle the flux of holiday parties with more graciousness!More, I previewed the menu on their website and was going to order the "Seafood Bowl - shrimp, lobster salad, lump grab, scallop and calamari ceviche, mussels, vinaigrette" as my starter, and "Long Island Duck Breast - sweet potato puree, snap peas, blood-orange citrus vinaigrette" asmy main dish. To make matters worse, a couple who had a large chocolate lab seating in the path way to the back room, (no one ever asked the couple to tuck the dog near the table, before getting stepped on or tripping a waiter) We had a running bet on the accident waiting to happen. We got a table immediately and then nothing happened . Beautiful garden setting. We met literally days into his opening of Caf Clover, where we created his famed white lentil risotto seen here on EyeSwoon. Fri, Sat 5:00 pm10:00 pm. created by Chef David Standridge of newly-renovated hotel The Maidstone. It's a mix of some paltry appetizers, a burger with no sides, a tiny strip of skirt steak with a pile of pickled onions, mushy Brussel sprouts and a few other forgettable choices. Our food is only getting better, Thank you. What is your go-to meal that you make at home often? Loud enough for us to hear :( Even the coffee was good. We used to come to the maidstone frequently. The food is great they have a backyard with a neon swing that you can swing on. Our server Greg was fantastic! 30 minutes for a drink to come incorrectly and the replacement took as long. Suggest an Edit, The Maidstone - 207 Main St, East Hampton, The Hedges Inn - 74 James Ln, East Hampton, 1770 House Restaurant & Inn - 143 Main St, East Hampton, 1770 House Restaurant & Inn - 143 Main St, The Palm - East Hampton - 94 Main St Suite 1800. Thank you for your honest feedback, for that's the best way to improve. Warm the lentils in a little olive oil and add the chopped herbs. Well be back!More, Sense of arrival isn't what it needs to be. Someone is training them well! Worse pancakes I ever had. Although not all meats were cooked to order they were happy to fix any errors and overall we had a very enjoyable experience. Felt limited. Would love to know what you ordered so we can make adjustments in the future. The waitstaff could not have been more attentive! The food was ok- the service was very slow, we were one of four groups of 2-4 at the entire restaurant. In a medium saucepan over high heat, sear the scallops in grapeseed oil. Appetizer out within 5 minutes, main course followed immediately, my plate taken away before my fork was even down, and then dessert menu in our faces right after that. Then slide the knife under the scallop to release from the shell. The menu they are now calling gastro-pub. I wanted to cut my losses. Tenminutes later we got a menu and ordered some wine then nothing happened for 40 minutes !! A mixture of a homemade pasta and "blistered" cherry tomatoes was one of the most creative dishes I have had in a long time on the East End. As a duck breast aficionado, I know that duck breast, cooked correctly, should be able to slice with one pass of the knife. Someone is training them well! Glad the Maidstone is back! Menu choices were limited but good tasting,especially the spaghetti with clam saucethe best ! Daily Baked Large Gourmet Chocolate Chip Cookie. What a shame to see such a beautiful space go downhill. Service was very slow and the food was soggy and full of oil. Menu is new with some staples from the past. I asked the front desk man if we could order some food , he was very friendly and embarrassed that we had not ordered yet . When I asked the waited what was taking so long, I told him I hoped they weren't overcooking it. Not only did we have a ton of fun cooking together again, this time around on the Eastern End of New York, but I also got to learn something completely new during our time in the kitchen. Valet parking available for select events, holidays and summer weekends. What would you say are the main tenets of flavor for a simple seafood? Upon arriving at the restaurant and looking at the menu I didn't see the Seafood Bowl and when I asked the waited I was told it was no longer available and they had to update the website. They both worked very hard And the bloody Mary was not much better. I definitely took a different approach. The owner should definitely be around more or this place will eventually close ! Then I took the two hour drive home. In all of its gooey, gory messiness, I LOVED pulling apart the ring of guts to reveal the pristine meat inside. We ordered the wedge salad (the bacon tasted freshly made, kudos to the chef) and the duck entree, which was served with orange sections, a sweet orange broth, and sweet potato pure. Shortrib noodles were lumpy and stuck together en mass on one big porridgelike serving. Dinner was a hot mess. Too bad as we have enjoyed eating there many times in the past. When asked if I had a sweet tooth, I just asked for the check. We ordered the wedge salad (the bacon tasted freshly made, kudos to the chef) and the duck entree, which was served with orange sections, a sweet orange broth, and sweet potato pure. Can't imagine that there was a manager on the floor and certainly didn't see anyone that might be one.More, It has been a while since we last went to the Maidstone. I finally was able to check in with our reservation upon which he told us to wait in the bar area20 minutes later one of our friends walks past to go to the ladies room and asked us why we were so late!!!! This made up for the flat gin and tonic (which came off the bill) when replaced with wine, and the sub par steamed mussels (no flavor or seasoning to the broth whatsoever). Later we drove past at 3am and every light in all 3 stories of the house was on but still couldnt see any people there. - Maidstone Management. The owner should definitely be around more or this place will eventually close ! We will not be back, My new go-to restaurant in East Hampton. Limited menu . And yet, many restaurants in the area have a tendency to serve fare that is far heavier than what Mother Nature offers. We left and went somewhere else for dinner. We went to the Maidstone Thusday , I have been going to the living room their eatery for years. The food itself was decent, but the entire experience wasnt worth the visit. Be sure to take a look at the story on MyDomaine as well. I asked for the bartender /server to bring me some goat cheese , he forgot so I had to ask again . Plenty of people milling about but no one pops up to greet and seat. (833) 953-2619 Website Seems like a full new staff and strong leadership. Salads are always excellent and local oysters on the half shell are another prime attraction. Skin could have been crispier, and duck more well done, but thats just my preference. Thank you for dining with us. Salmon had to be sent back 2x. And absolutely not worth the money ! No longer a great dining experience. Hotels with Complimentary Breakfast in East Hampton, Hotels with Private Beach in East Hampton, Hotels near Pollock-Krasner House and Study Center, Hotels near Ross Institute Center for Well-Being, Hotels near Elevated East Efoil Surfboard Rentals, Hotels near (ISP) Long Island MacArthur Airport, American Restaurants for Breakfast in East Hampton, American Restaurants for Special Occasions in East Hampton, American Restaurants with Outdoor Seating in East Hampton, Mediterranean Restaurants in East Hampton, Restaurants for Special Occasions in East Hampton. - Maidstone Management. The space is lovely with a beautiful garden and amazing photos all over the walls. Food is 5 star perfection! Wow. During this Covid-19 transition especially with the lack of staffing, we strive to accommodate all of our guests needs. The only bright spot to the dinner was our waiter Marcos who was very nice and attentive. Although not all meats were cooked to order they were happy to fix any errors and overall we had a very enjoyable experience. Not the old Maidstone but a nice change from many of the stiff restaurants on the East End. The property truly embodies Hamptons charm. I ordered a goat cheese salad and a side dish . My cooking sesh and scallop-and beverage-filled morning with Chef David may have been a bit fanciful, but it was also apropos. We did not get our salad until an hour later on top of that - no goat cheese on my salad ! Thank you for dining with us and we are striving daily to improve our service and the quality of our food. The bar tender then was sharing true stories about women with a friend at the bar ! No bartender, no host, no waiters, no other guests. We always looked forward to coming to the maidstone for dinner, not anymore. During this Covid-19 transition especially with the lack of staffing, we strive to accommodate all of our guests needs. So much going on . The kitchen ran out of fish, by 7:00, the drinks took over 20 min to arrive at our table- then when we finished by 9:30 we were told the kitchen had closed, dessert wasnt available and that the espresso machine was broken. Next time I going to stay for the week. Spoon a little of the butter mixture over each scallop and serve with a wedge of lime. Eggs are what I always have in my fridge. The front desk man was really nice and tried as hard as he could to do his best . We sat near the fireplace which always adds to the ambiance of any meal. We had a nice (Apple/citrus finish) Sauvignon Blanc by the glass - the restaurant has a wonderful variety of by-the-glass wines for every palate. Based on dinner the other night I have a feeling there will be yet another theme next year. Recommend the crostini, the gnocchi and the macro bowl but I dont think you can makea wrong choice. Shortrib noodles were lumpy and stuck together en mass on one big porridgelike serving. Diners beneath it complain so it gets shut off. Offering set menus for Holiday Gatherings this holiday season. We had two courses and were out in 40 minutes. Wow. Great music , celebrity sightings Emma Roberts and Paul McCarthy both separately eating and drinking so much fun.